Skip to content

The thing about the thing about the booing

by on April 9, 2013

By now we all know Carlos Marmol got booed yesterday during player introductions and again when he entered the game and pitching a scoreless 8th inning.

So where am I with this?

The booing doesn’t feel right, but I’m not gonna be as quick as others to condemn it. It’s true that the context of both booing episodes was inappropriate, and maybe I’m being naive when I say I believe that had the season opened at Wrigley, Marmol would have heard cheers during the intros and even when called on for the save (of course those would have turned quickly to boos if he pitched as he did in his first appearance in Pittsburgh).

But I can’t really blame fans for expressing disapproval that had been building over the first week of the season. The folly of inserting Marmol to preserve 9th inning leads was becoming increasingly obvious to everyone watching. It feels to me more like those fans were booing not so much of Marmol the pitcher (and of course not Marmol the person) as voicing their disapproval of the role  he had been assigned on the club.

You may think I’m giving the fans too much credit here, but I’m not necessarily talking about the booing as a conscious indictment of Marmol’s handling, which hasn’t been helping anyone, but as a primal scream directed at something obviously broken.

Did Marmol deserve to be booed? No. Did the Cubs’ use of Marmol this season deserve to booed? Yes. Is that a good enough excuse? I don’t know.

This stirs up some stuff in me, I guess. I often feel that Cubs fans have to ride a line in a way that, say, Phillies fans don’t. There’s a dual set of knocks on Cubs fans: that we unfairly boo players for poor performance (I’ll just leave it at that; there are nastier versions of thisone); and an opposite criticism that we’re a complacent and don’t care about winning or losing (the most infuriating thing Dave Eggers ever wrote does not help).

Where does that leave us? Seems to me this should probably be a year to take our lumps as a bunch of drunks who don’t care whether our team wins or loses. Hopefully we’ll have plenty of time to be high-strung in the not-too-distant future.

From → Uncategorized

  1. Scott Rutkowski permalink

    Whichever stereotype fits other people’s opinion at the time will be the one that is used. Just like all of Lakeview is inhabited by polo wearing, collar popped citizens.

    I agree with your statement as well.

  2. Scott Rutkowski permalink

    I remember reading that Dave Eggers article, but I re-read it because I have forgotten most of it. What a simplistic take on Cubs fans. And he was doing it from rooftop seats where 75 people in a wedding were reminiscing about last night. Then he talks about people outside the ballpark who sounded like every person who sits in the bleachers and the rooftops. Not the people who sit in the terraces and the upper deck.

    The only thing that saved this article was the last paragraph about the importance of Wrigley Field and history. I’m also amazed that whoever took him to Wrigley Field as a child did not teach him about the importance of the game. If you were going to a Cubs game, as a kid, and the person taking you was showing you the importance of the game then you went with the wrong person.

    Personally, this is my favorite article about Wrigley

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: